Shiva, The Nataraja : An Enigma of Many Manifestations

Article of the Month - Aug 2021

This article by Prof. P.C. Jain and Dr Daljeet.

(Viewed 18164 times since Aug 2021)



An image or an aspect of Shiva’s person

The question ‘Is Shiva’s manifestation as Nataraja an aspect of Shiva’s person or just one of the types of his image in art or worship tradition’ has always haunted the minds of thinkers. As for art critics they have invariably confined themselves to his various manifestations as reveal in his iconographic forms – image-type, and there ends their quest.

Contrarily metaphysicians and theologians perceived his form as it manifested in the Upanishads and Puranas. They perceived him as representing one of the ‘Tri-murti’ – three forms or functional aspects of God, namely, creation, preservation and dissolution, that is, bringing the cosmos into existence, sustaining it and finally withdrawing it.

Trimurti From Elephanta (Brahma, Vishnu and Mahesha)

Lord Shiva was seen as representing the last of these three aspects, that is, dissolution. Prajapati, or Brahma, and Vishnu were seen as representing other two aspects, creation and preservation. In some contexts the Rig-Veda mentioned Prajapati and Brahma as two independent gods but sometimes also as two names of the Creator. Hence, they were often seen as representing one and the same functional aspect of God.

Shiva in Vedic literature

The Shiva-related worship tradition showed two trends. Under one, Shiva was seen as ‘ling’ – his aniconic manifestation;  and, under the other, he was seen and worshipped with a very wide range of imagery Nataraja being one of such forms.

He was seen as Sadashiva, One beyond time and beyond ‘kalpa’ – the scheduled tenure of the Creation, that is, time that spanned everything – manifest or unmanifest, was not Shiva’s measuring scale. In Indian cosmological tabulation Shiva's life-span is double of Vishnu, and Vishnu's, double of Brahma. Thus, in one kalpa Brahma emerges twice, Vishnu’s tenure ends with every kalpa; Shiva has tenure beyond kalpa.


Sadashiva (Five-Headed Shiva)

The underlying mystic vein effectively working in the Shaivite worship cult saw Shiva as seed – the root of all things and all beings, male or female, and this gave to his visual image, both in art as well as to enshrine a sanctum a new image form known as Ardhanarishvara – half male and half female.

The mystics contended that it was after Shiva split that there came forth both life and matter – ‘pran’ and ‘bhuta’. The Rig-Veda proclaimed in one of the Suktas ‘he (the Rig-Veda does not link this ‘he’ with Shiva but generalizes it) is as much male, as the female’. The ‘Advaita’ philosophy also contends that the entire Creation is just the extension of One.

Large Ardhanarishvara (Shiva Shakti) - Brocadeless Thangka

All forms of dance initiated

Expressive of two basic tendencies of mind – wrathfulness and delight to include amour and enjoyment of beauty, dance was later classified as ‘tandava’ and ‘lasya; that is, what revealed wrath was classified as ‘tandava’, and that which revealed delight, also amour, ‘lasya’, ‘tandava’ revealing destructive mood, and ‘lasya’, creative.

Theologians contend that dance is Shiva’s instrument for both, to create and to dissolve. They hold that his body wrathfully whirled as in dance when he destroyed Tripura – the cluster of three cities sheltering three demon brothers.

Tripurantaka Shiva

 They also contend that immenseness of his ire was absolute when in it the entire universe dissolved. Thus, immensity of wrath determined the class of ‘tandava’, if it was the dance of dissolution or the dance that destroyed an individual or some particular object. Shiva resorted to a dance form similar to 'anandatandava' also when destroying elephant demon Gaya, demon Andhaka and when accomplishing Trailokyavijaya – victory of three worlds.

 

Anandatandava - The Dance of Absolute Bliss (Nataraja)

In similar vein metaphysicians hold that universe, his manifestation, creation and dissolution, wherever occurring, occur in him. If a leaf falls and decomposes, it is he who decays, and if a new shoot bursts, it is he who re-emerges. It is he who effects creation as also dissolution and is yet above both. Thus, unlike a conceptual deity-image for sanctum an image of Shiva engaged in dance, despite that it also involves a lot of symbolism and is highly artistic, portrays an essential aspect of his being.

Dance illustrates one of the ever-first cosmic acts with which Shiva seems to have tamed violent motion and separated from it rhythm, moves that communicated emotions and states of mind – human mind and the cosmic, and disciplined and defined pace. Cosmos emerged with roaring horizons, tempestuous winds, turbulent oceans, rocking mountains and moving earths. Shiva arrested their unruliness into his limbs and noises into the beats of his drum.

Lord Shiva in Ecstatic Dance

His feet re-cast the unruly skies and violent waters, and all their cries and commotion. Thus, unruly sounds were set to syllabic discipline, and cosmic disorder, having been reduced to measured pace, was transformed into ordered movement. A man of stage from his body gestures and movements he revealed, and perhaps guided how to reveal, different emotions and states of mind.

He danced in delight as also to destroy. Thus in his case neither a dance-image nor any is an artistic manipulation or just an image for sanctum. Each of his images represents one of his aspects, an aspect of mind but more truly that of the flesh.

Dimensions of tandava and lasya manifesting in Shiva

Shaivite thought – metaphysical as well as devotional, abounds in numerous myths of dance performed by Shiva and his consort Devi in her various manifestations. Unlike Vishnu who resorted to dance for accomplishing a contemplated objective, Shiva has been conceived more or less as a regular dancer performing for accomplishing an objective as also for pure aesthetic delight.

The tradition hence reveres him, besides as 'Adi-nratya-guru' – the originator and the first teacher of dance, also as Natesh or Nataraja – the king of dance. In him revealed both faces of dance – 'lasya' as well as 'tandava', of which all subsequent dance forms were offshoots. 'Lasya', the dance of aesthetic delight revealed beauty, grace, love and all tender aspects of existence.

21" Dancing Shiva Parvati | Handmade | Madhuchista Vidhana (Lost-Wax) | Panchaloha Bronze from Swamimalai

'Lasya' is the mode that defined many of Shiva's iconographic forms – Kalyana-Sundara, Vrashavahana, Yogeshvara, Katyavalambita, Sukhasanamurti, Chinamudra, Anugrahamurti, and Chandrashekhara. Vyakhyanamurti Chinamudra, Anugrahamurti, and Chandrashekhar.


Superfine 80" Large Nataraja | Handmade | Madhuchista Vidhana (Lost-Wax) | Panchaloha Bronze from Swamimalai | Made In India

'Tandava' – more correctly 'ananda-tandava', was the dance of absolute bliss, for after the Great Age had ended and dissolution had become imperative, He – the Great Shiva, Who alone remained to effect 're-birth' of life on the cosmos, danced in absolute bliss over the head of dissolution. In visual arts dissolution has been represented as Apasmarapurusha, the demon of forgetfulness and darkness, which prevailed after dissolution.

Sound, which vibrated the space – the first of the five elements – the basic constituents of creation, fire, the symbol of final conflagration as also of the re-birth of energy – the main source of life, and gestures of re-assurance, fearlessness, release and liberation, accompanied 'ananda-tandava' as its organs.

These aspects largely concretized also his image in ananda-tandava as it manifested in art and worship tradition especially in South where Shiva is widely worshipped as Nataraja. In ananda-tandava imagery Shiva carried a damaru – double drum suggestive of sound – an essential component of ananda-tandava.

Ananda-tandava conceived Shiva’s image with flames of fire bursting from one of his palms and as running through entire cosmos – symbolized in Shaivite imagery in the form of a fire-arch. Similarly, assurance, freedom from fear, release … are revealed in the gestures of Shiva’s hands.

It was in 'ananda-tandava' that the fivefold activity – creating, maintaining, veiling, unveiling, and destroying, and the six celestial 'bhavas': 'shrishti' – creation; 'sanhara' – dissolution; 'vidya' – knowledge; 'avidya' – ignorance; 'gati' – motion; and 'agati' – inertness, revealed. 'Ananda-tandava', thus, encompassed the entire cosmos and its phenomenal existence.

Informal image

In almost all manifestations Shiva’s images are informal though in a dance form such aspect is best revealed. In a dance form the impassioned Shiva is as a rule portrayed as passionately engaged in it each body-part involving in its ecstasy.

Unfurling locks of hair and his snakes floating into space portray the dynamics of the act. Usually he his right leg planted on the figure of Apasmarapurusha, and the left, turned to the right and shot with sublime force into the space.

 

58" Large Bhagawan Shiva | Mahadeva Shiva | Brass Statue | Handmade | Made In India

Shiva is usually a figure with normal two arms though his images portraying him as engaged in dance are often four-armed. Besides the normal right and left hands held in ‘abhay’and ‘varad’, the upper right hand carries a double-drum, and the upper left, a flame of fire. The term Nataraja, composed of’Nata’ and ’Raja’ literally means ’king’ of ’natas’.

However, in its width the term ‘nata’, an ’acrobat’, means stage-performer. Thus, Nataraja means king of stage-performers or dancers. Shiva danced to destroy and to create or to delight, but containing unruly motion and to make it the instrument of expressing ‘bhavas’, an impulse that required him to teach it to others, also made him the ever first teacher – 'Adiguru' of dance.

Some other significant image forms of Shiva in dance 

Later, Shiva was celebrated also as Nratya Dakshinamurti – one who is 'daksha' or expert in dance and also as Natesh. Though the terms Natesh and Nratya Dakshinamurti had greater breadth for these terms also included ‘lasya’, besides ‘tandava’, his form that the term Nataraja denoted is largely rigidified, has a better defined iconography and in common perception is seen as better representing Shiva in 'Ananda-tandava' – the dance of dissolution.

Lord Shiva: Nataraja or Nratya Dakshinamurti

Various forms of Apasamarapurusha – as variously decoded by Shaivite thinkers, present also some variants of this form. Though ruthlessly trampled under the feet in most cases the image of Apasamarapurusha lies well contented as if awaiting the end of the dance and complete dissolution of the cosmos for after the dissolution is absolute its reign – the reign of inertness, begins.

Sometimes Apasamarapurusha is thoughtfully inclined as if meditating on how it shall act after dissolution has taken place, and sometimes carries a flower or some object assuring that soon the process of re-creation shall begin.

 

This article by P.C. Jain and Dr Daljeet 


For Further Reference:
  • Rigveda : (ed.) Vishvabandhu : Vishveshvananda Vedic Research Institute, Hoshiyarpur
  • Shiva Purana, Gita Press, Gorakhpur
  • Upanishad-anka, Gita Press, Gorakhpur
  • Linga Purana : (ed.) J. L. Shashtri, Delhi
  • Natyashashtra by Bharata Muni
  • A Concise Encyclopaedia of Hinduism, Ram Krishna Math, Benglore
  • Shivaramamurti : Nataraja in Art, Thought and Literature
  • V. S. Agrawal : Shiva Mahadeva, The Great God : Varanasi
  • Stella Kramrisch : The Presence Of Shiva : Delhi
  • Devdutt Pattanaik : Shiva, an Introduction
Add a review

Your email address will not be published *

  • Prabhus, Back in the hippie days of this country, I was tripping on LSD in a study hall class in High School in 1968. What I will relate to you here is part of the legacy in my search and discovery of the Kundalini, as well as something I have told many others about over the years. We all know LSD creates visual patterns and transcendental effects, but this trip was unique and others happened to me like it. I was staring out of theschool window looking at the psychedelic colors move in and out of the clouds, on a sunny summer day. Suddenly, I noticed something going on in my throat area, around where the vishudda cakra would be. What ever was happening there was unrelated to the colors and tripping phenomenon that I was undergoing. So my attention was drawn to this stuff happening in my throat, and my attention went there. I was surprised to see a little figure there, a small man, who was chrome or silver color, dancing on a pedestal structure from leg to leg as he turned around also. His shape and form was unmistakable and was definitely a small human figure dancing from leg to leg. His shape was very clear. As my attention went to this being, he immediately began to grow in size. He suddenly zoomed up through my throat, then my head and face, looking me right in the eye as he passed upward. He then zoomed out of my head out through the top, the area of what I now know of as the Sahasrara Cakra, exploding with a torrent of bliss I experienced. I let out a strong "AHHHHH", so much so the all the other students turned and looked to see what was happening. I was shocked and surprised at what happened!! Slowly the bliss went away, the being whoever it was, was gone, and the regular aspect of the trip resumed, without my understanding what happened. I thought about what had happened, for days after the trip. A few days later I was in the french quarter of New Orleans, as we lived not far from that city. I was walking down the street just looking into various shop windows, and I was awstruck-in the window of one shop was a Natraraja, and the exact form of the being in the center of the Nataraja was the man that had appeared in my throat in the LSD experience just a few days before. Now, this is the thing-I had never seen a Nataraja before, knew nothing of Shiva or anything related to Hinduism before. I stood there shocked at what I saw in the store window-closely studying the form. It was unmistakable, what appeared in my lower throat and zoomed up through my head was the same figure in the shop window, minus the ring around it. So when someone says that the Nataraja is just a mythical art or cultural form of Shiva, let them read this. Namaste, atmabhoda, Sarasvati
    Rick May 06, 2020